Math Mystery Worksheet Generator (Solve the Clues, Find the Culprit)

Print a two-page math whodunit for ages 7–11. Read the case, meet six suspects, then solve each clue's problems: the answers tell you who to cross out, and the last suspect standing did it. Pick the case and the skill, three or four clue sets, and an answer key.

Every mystery has exactly one culprit: each clue crosses out at least one suspect and only one survives all of them. Page 1 holds the case, the suspects and clues 1–2; page 2 the rest and the culprit box. One page fits the whole mystery on a single sheet.

Go to print queue →4 clue sets · 3 pages
Math Mystery · Addition & Subtraction within 20
The Case of the Hidden Dinosaur Books

Someone hid every dinosaur book in the school library! The librarian found a trail of muddy footprints by the door.

Solve the problems in each clue. Use your answers to cross out suspects. The last one left did it!
AAbe
Hat
yes
Shirt
green
Pet
bird
Badge
11
BBella
Hat
no
Shirt
green
Pet
frog
Badge
23
CCal
Hat
no
Shirt
purple
Pet
bird
Badge
54
DDina
Hat
yes
Shirt
orange
Pet
frog
Badge
82
EEzra
Hat
no
Shirt
purple
Pet
dog
Badge
52
GGia
Hat
yes
Shirt
red
Pet
bird
Badge
92
Clue 1

The culprit's badge number is GREATER than the answer to problem 1.

  1. 118 − 4 =
  2. 28 − 4 =
  3. 39 + 7 =
  4. 413 + 5 =
Cross out:AAbeBBellaCCalDDinaEEzraGGia
Clue 2

Add up all 4 answers. If the total is EVEN, the culprit wears a hat. If the total is ODD, the culprit has no hat.

  1. 112 + 7 =
  2. 220 − 14 =
  3. 38 − 5 =
  4. 43 − 2 =
Cross out:AAbeBBellaCCalDDinaEEzraGGia
Math Mystery · Addition & Subtraction within 20 · continued
The Case of the Hidden Dinosaur Books
Keep solving. Cross out more suspects until only one is left.
Clue 3

The answer to problem 3 is the TENS digit of the culprit's badge number.

  1. 19 + 10 =
  2. 211 + 5 =
  3. 315 − 10 =
  4. 418 − 16 =
Cross out:AAbeBBellaCCalDDinaEEzraGGia
Clue 4

Find the answer to problem 4 in the pet code. That is the culprit's pet.

Pet code:13 = dog14 = bird11 = frog
  1. 18 + 12 =
  2. 27 + 5 =
  3. 317 + 2 =
  4. 46 + 8 =
Cross out:AAbeBBellaCCalDDinaEEzraGGia
SuspectHatShirtPetBadge
A Abeyesgreenbird11
B Bellanogreenfrog23
C Calnopurplebird54
D Dinayesorangefrog82
E Ezranopurpledog52
G Giayesredbird92
The culprit is
Answer KeyThe Case of the Hidden Dinosaur Books
Clue 1
11424316418
Problem 1 = 14 → badge greater than 14
Cross out: Abe
Clue 2
119263341
Total = 29, odd → no hat
Cross out: Dina, Gia
Clue 3
1192163542
Problem 3 = 5 → badge has 5 tens
Cross out: Bella
Clue 4
120212319414
Problem 4 = 14 → pet bird
Cross out: Ezra
The culprit is Cal!